
I like science too. Here, I made you a venn diagram that accurately represents this research's findings.
So I don’t know how many of you were checking out page 17 of yesterday’s Herald Sun, but neatly sandwiched between a story about musical instruments being refused as hand-luggage and the supposed missing link between prehistoric and modern man was an interesting little piece about how gamers are quite likely to have bad teeth. I’ve conveniently scanned it for you, or you can peruse the online version if you’d like.
In some research undertaken by the University of Iowa that would make Captain Obvious hang his head in shame, it’s apparently been established as a solid fact that young gamers are twice as likely to suffer from tooth decay because of their “propensity to wolf down sugary snacks and drinks”. OK. Fine. No argument here. As a man in his twenties who has to drink around a litre of Coke a day just to calm the shakes, I’ll admit to the fact that I’m probably not going to be the first in line to star in a Macleans ad.
But what baffles me is this: why the fuck are video games even being mentioned in this article at all?
Let’s look at the facts. The study focuses on adolescent children from the age of 12 to 16, presumably because this can be an important time in regards to your dental health. According to the research, as young gamers love to eat sugary snacks (as no doubt they presumably murder people and kill hookers on screen, tut tut), their chance of suffering tooth decay is twice as high.
But wait a second? What’s this here in the results?
The research … also found that those who had parental rules regarding screen time and diet were less likely to eat or drink while watching TV and playing games than those who did not.
Wow, you think? Good to see someone has finally gotten onto that whole “what causes tooth decay” issue. Sugar is bad for enamel? Really? Why didn’t anyone tell us this earlier?
Of course, as the story goes on to mention, they did:
The findings were backed up by the vice-president of the Australian Dental Association, Anne Stewart.
“It’s not really a surprise,” she said. “These studies are backing up what is already known about the tooth decay process and we have been telling patients for years about the snacking problem.”
And that’s where this whole thing flies apart and justifies it’s page 17 status. It’s not a video game problem, it’s a snacking problem, and in this study it’s inexorably tied to the parents of the children in question. If they’d bothered to simply observe normal gamers in comparison to non-gamers, then maybe we’d have some conclusive evidence here, but all this studay actually shows is that people who don’t look after their teeth will eventually get bad teeth. I hope you didn’t overshoot the budget on that one, University of Iowa!
Honestly, gaming has only been crowbarred in here to add some sensationalism to the research, just a flavour of the month to bash alongside the rather valid claims of links with childhood obesity and somewhat more questionable claims of increased violent tendencies. I mean if they had of just published the findings that parents who let their kids eat candy all day increase their childrens’ vulnerability to tooth decay, people would have handed them the phone and told them it was the 1940′s calling for their research back.
So frankly parents, if you make sure to instill proper eating habits and oral hygeine in your children, you’re actually free to let them play as many games as they damn well want to. Or if you’re still fretting over the whole matter, then why not combine the two activities?